Home / Briefings / Vehicle Dynamics Assessment

Vehicle Dynamics Assessment: Impact Speed, Angle and Rating at Every Barrier Line

A vehicle dynamics assessment (VDA) calculates how fast, at what angle and with how much energy a hostile vehicle can reach each barrier line on a site. PNH Security Engineering Consultants performs VDAs independently, so every barrier rating is set by the site, not by a product catalog.

Technical guide by Pedram Hesam, PhD, PSP, Chief Technical Officer, PNH Security Engineering Consultants. Updated .

What is a vehicle dynamics assessment?

A vehicle dynamics assessment is an engineering calculation of the speed, approach angle and kinetic energy a credible threat vehicle can reach at each point where a barrier line will stop it. It answers the owner's question: how fast can a vehicle actually hit this barrier?

The answer is rarely the top speed of the vehicle. It is set by the ground the vehicle has to cover: how far it can accelerate, which bends force it to slow down, what slopes help or hinder it, and what stands in its way. A VDA traces each credible route from its start point to the barrier line, solves the speed along the whole route, and reports the impact condition at the line.

A VDA is one part of a full vehicle ramming assessment, which also identifies the assets and crowds to protect, reviews existing measures and ranks each location. Terms used here are defined in the protective design glossary.

Which standards call for a vehicle dynamics assessment?

A vehicle dynamics assessment is called for by ISO 22343-2:2023, the international application standard for vehicle security barriers, and by UK NPSA guidance; U.S. criteria use the same calculation under other names. ISO 22343-2 (first edition, September 2023) says a VDA should be undertaken as part of the site survey (7.3) to evaluate the speed a threat vehicle can reach at a specific location, and treats it in subclause 9.2.2, alongside road layout (9.2.3), speed reduction features (9.2.4) and impact angle (9.3).

The UK National Protective Security Authority (NPSA) lists a VDA at specific locations, based on the relevant threat vehicles, as a technical assessment option for hostile vehicle mitigation, and recommends considering a full range of threat vehicles and impact speeds. NPSA and NaCTSO guidance on temporary barriers likewise points to a VDA by a certified professional.

In U.S. criteria, UFC 4-022-02, Selection and Application of Vehicle Barriers (2009, Change 1, 2010), sets out methods for attainable speed on straight approaches and through curves, impact angle and kinetic energy in Sections 4-4 and 4-5.

Inputs: what a VDA needs to know

A VDA needs the threat vehicles, their performance limits and the geometry of every route they could take.

  • Threat vehicle classes and masses. Usually the test vehicles of the standard the barriers will be rated to: ASTM F2656/F2656M-23 runs from a 2,420 lb small passenger car (SC), a 4,630 lb full-size sedan and a 5,000 lb pickup to a 15,000 lb medium-duty truck (M) and a 65,000 lb heavy goods vehicle; ISO 22343-1:2023 runs from a 1,500 kg car (M1) to trucks of up to 30,000 kg (N3G).
  • Acceleration and braking limits for each vehicle, which differ widely between a loaded truck, a passenger car and an electric vehicle.
  • Start points. Where a vehicle can begin its run: a public street, a parking area, a loading dock, an adjacent lot, or a vehicle already moving at road speed.
  • Run-up length along each route, measured on the path a vehicle would actually drive.
  • Curves and the lateral grip limit, which cap the speed through each bend; for tall trucks, rollover can govern before tires slide.
  • Surface and gradients: pavement, grass, gravel and wet conditions change grip; downhill runs add speed, uphill runs remove it.
  • Obstacles: curbs, trees, walls, planters, structures and changes in level that block, slow or redirect a vehicle, and the gaps between them.

Method: how the speed at each barrier line is solved

A VDA solves a speed profile route by route: the vehicle accelerates where it can, slows where the geometry forces it to, and arrives at the barrier line with a calculated speed and angle.

  • Speed from acceleration over distance. On a straight run from rest, speed grows with the square root of distance (speed equals the square root of twice the acceleration times the distance). Doubling the run-up raises speed only about 41 percent.
  • Speed limit through a curve. A vehicle can only hold a bend as fast as its lateral grip allows; that limit grows with the square root of the curve radius. A tight turn close to the line can cut the impact speed sharply, which is why UFC 4-022-02 notes that a curved path can be designed so that a faster vehicle skids.
  • Approach angle at the line. The direction of travel at the line sets the impact angle. UFC 4-022-02 resolves the speed into its component perpendicular to the barrier for energy checks; the angle also decides whether the tested condition of a barrier applies at all.
  • Kinetic energy. Energy grows with mass and with the square of speed, so 40 mph carries about 78 percent more energy than 30 mph for the same vehicle.

Illustrative example only. A 5,000 lb pickup sustaining a constant 0.35 g (about 11.3 ft per second squared, the acceleration UFC 4-022-02 uses in its example for a high-performance car) from rest on level pavement reaches the speeds below. Real acceleration falls as speed rises, and a loaded 15,000 lb truck accelerates far more slowly but carries three times the mass, so a site assessment solves each threat vehicle with its own limits.

Straight run-up from restSpeed reached at 0.35 gKinetic energy of a 5,000 lb pickup at that speed
85 ftabout 30 mphabout 149 ft-kips (202 kJ)
150 ftabout 40 mphabout 263 ft-kips (356 kJ)
240 ftabout 50 mphabout 420 ft-kips (569 kJ)

Put a 60 ft radius bend whose exit is 20 ft before the line, with the friction factor of 0.6 that UFC 4-022-02 says is usually used on a roadway, and the same pickup can carry only about 23 mph through it. Even accelerating hard after the bend, it reaches the line at about 27 mph, however long the straight before it; with the more conservative factor of 1.0 it is about 33 mph, still inside the 28.0 to 37.9 mph band of a 30 mph rating. Geometry, not the vehicle, often governs.

Run-up sets speed; bends cap it
Two illustrative charts. Left: speed reached from rest on a straight run-up at a constant 0.35 g, about 29.8 mph at 85 ft, 39.6 mph at 150 ft and 50.1 mph at 240 ft, with a dashed slower-vehicle curve and the ASTM F2656 30, 40 and 50 mph test speed bands. Right: maximum speed through a curve against radius for friction factors 0.6 and 1.0, about 23.2 and 30.0 mph at a 60 ft radius.Speed from a straight run-up, from restv = sqrt(2 a s)Maximum speed through a curvev = sqrt(f g r)30 mph rating band28.0 to 37.9 mph40 mph rating band38.0 to 46.9 mph50 mph rating band47.0 mph and above0102030405060Speed (mph)0102030405060Speed (mph)050100150200250300Straight run-up from rest (ft)205080110140170200Curve radius (ft)85 ft: 29.8 mph150 ft: 39.6 mph240 ft: 50.1 mph0.35 gSlower vehicle23.2 mph30.0 mph60 ft radiusf = 0.6f = 1.00.35 g, about 11.3 ft/s² (UFC 4-022-02 example value)Slower vehicle (illustrative)ASTM F2656 30, 40 and 50 mph test speed bandsf = 0.6, usually used on a roadway (UFC 4-022-02)f = 1.0, more conservativeExit 20 ft before the line, then 0.35 g: about 27 mphat the line with f = 0.6, about 33 mph with f = 1.0.Illustrative. Constant acceleration on level pavement from rest; real acceleration falls as speed rises. g = 32.2 ft/s².Each threat vehicle is solved with its own limits. Bands per ASTM F2656/F2656M-23 for the M truck; PU50 ends at 56.9 mph.
Illustrative only: constant 0.35 g from rest on level pavement (about 11.3 ft per second squared, the UFC 4-022-02 example value), and curve speed limits for the friction factor of 0.6 that UFC 4-022-02 says is usually used and the more conservative 1.0. Real acceleration falls as speed rises, so each threat vehicle is solved with its own limits.

Outputs: what a VDA reports for each barrier line

For every barrier line and every credible route to it, a VDA reports the impact condition and the barrier performance that condition requires.

  • Threat vehicle and route that govern the line
  • Impact speed at the line
  • Impact angle at the line
  • Kinetic energy at impact
  • Required test rating (vehicle and speed) under the standard the project uses
  • Allowable penetration, set by the clear distance between the barrier line and the asset or crowd behind it, less the part of the vehicle ahead of the rating's reference point (the cab and engine of a truck)
What penetration measures, and the space to keep clear
Illustrative side elevation of a box truck stopped after hitting a bollard. Penetration of 2.6 m is measured from the barrier datum to the leading lower edge of the cargo bed; the cab and engine stop further forward, a major debris piece lands 5.0 m from the datum, and people, queues and stalls belong beyond both, with a margin.Side elevation after impact: what penetration measures and how much space to keep clearReference point:leading lower edgeof the cargo bedBox truck,stoppedCab and engine stopahead of the reference pointPeople, queues, seating, stallsstart beyond the clear zoneDatum: ISO 22343-1 VSB datum line (foremost point of the structure designed to withstandthe impact); ASTM F2656 pre-test leading impact edge. Measured from the original front face.Barrier, deformed(dashed: before impact)Major debris(furthest piece)Rated penetration: 2.6 m (8.5 ft), datum to reference pointFurthest part of the vehicle (reported under ISO 22343-1)Major debris distance: 5.0 m (16.4 ft)Clear zone: beyond the furthest vehicle point and the major debris, plus margin01 m2 m3 m4 m5 m6 m7 m8 m9 mDistance from the datumIllustrative. Values from the example rating code V/7200[N3C]/48/90:2.6/5.0, not a test result. Truck drawn approximately to scale.ASTM F2656 rates penetration only (P1 up to 1 m, P2 to 7 m, P3 to 30 m) and does not rate debris.
Illustrative values from the example rating code V/7200[N3C]/48/90:2.6/5.0. Penetration is measured from the barrier datum to the vehicle reference point, so the cab and engine of a truck stop further forward; allowable penetration is the clear distance to the asset or crowd, less the part of the vehicle ahead of the reference point.

How VDA results map to ASTM F2656 and ISO 22343-1 ratings

The right rating for a location is the lowest tested condition whose vehicle, actual test speed, angle and penetration meet or exceed what the VDA calculated for that line.

ASTM F2656/F2656M-23. Condition designations combine a test vehicle and a nominal speed. For the 15,000 lb medium-duty truck (M):

DesignationNominal speedPermissible test speed rangeNominal kinetic energy
M3030 mph (50 km/h)28.0 to 37.9 mph451 ft-kips (612 kJ)
M4040 mph (65 km/h)38.0 to 46.9 mph802 ft-kips (1,088 kJ)
M5050 mph (80 km/h)47.0 mph and above1,250 ft-kips (1,700 kJ)

The 5,000 lb pickup (PU) uses the same 30 and 40 mph bands; PU50 spans 47.0 to 56.9 mph and PU60 starts at 57.0 mph.

The energies are one-half the mass times the speed squared for the 15,000 lb truck at the nominal mph speed, rounded, with kilojoules converted directly from the same calculation; energies computed at the nominal km/h speeds of F2656M (50, 65 and 80 km/h) differ slightly (656, 1,109 and 1,680 kJ). The penetration rating states how far the vehicle traveled past the barrier: P1 is 3.3 ft (1 m) or less, P2 is 3.31 to 23.0 ft (1.01 to 7 m), and P3 is 23.1 to 98.4 ft (7.01 to 30 m), with P2 and P3 reported together with the measured distance, for example P2:6.4 m. Penetration is measured from the barrier's pre-test leading impact edge to the vehicle reference point, which is the leading lower edge of the cargo bed for trucks and the base of the A-pillar for cars and pickups. Because an M30 test may have been run anywhere from 28.0 to 37.9 mph, PNH reads the actual test speed in the test report, not only the designation, against the speed the VDA calculated.

ISO 22343-1:2023 (first edition, which cancels and replaces IWA 14-1:2013) rates a barrier by the test vehicle class and mass, the impact speed recorded in the test, the impact angle and the measured vehicle penetration distance beyond the VSB datum line (the foremost point of the barrier structure designed to withstand the impact), rather than by speed bands; a rating reads, for example, V/7200[N3C]/48/90:2.6/5.0 (an illustrative code: a 7,200 kg N3C truck at 48 km/h and 90 degrees, 2.6 m vehicle penetration, 5.0 m major debris distance). IWA 14-1:2013 and PAS 68 are withdrawn, but NPSA treats existing results to them as valid unless the as-tested barrier has been changed.

Seen from above: three separate approaches, three different ratings
Illustrative site plan seen from above: three separate approaches to one barrier line whose ends tie into buildings. A 240 ft straight run-up from rest gives a 5,000 lb pickup about 50 mph and needs a PU50 rating; an 85 ft run from a loading dock gives about 30 mph and needs PU30; a 60 ft radius bend 20 ft before the line holds the pickup to about 23 mph, so it reaches the line at about 27 mph and PU30 is enough.BuildingBuildingBuildingBuildingBuildingParking structureexit(start, from rest)Loading dock(start, from rest)Bollards close each opening;building walls form the restPROTECTED PLAZA240 ft straight run-up85 ft from the loading dock20 ft60 ft radius bend:about 23 mph at mostFrom the street,any run-upABCLine A: long straightAbout 50 mph at the lineAbout 420 ft-kips (569 kJ)PU50Line B: loading dockAbout 30 mph at the lineAbout 149 ft-kips (202 kJ)PU30Line C: bend before the lineAbout 27 mph at the lineAbout 125 ft-kips (169 kJ)PU30Bollard detail, enlarged (plan)About 40 in clear, including at each wall0 to 100 ftIllustrative: 5,000 lb pickup, 0.35 g from rest,friction factor 0.6 in the bend (UFC 4-022-02).Bollards to scale, about 40 in clear. Not a real site.
Illustrative only: a 5,000 lb pickup accelerating at 0.35 g from rest, with the friction factor of 0.6 that UFC 4-022-02 says is usually used in the bend. Buildings close every route on both sides, so the approaches cannot be cut across, and bollards at about 40 in clear close each opening between building walls.

Why a single worst-case straight-line check gets it wrong

A single straight-line check over-specifies some lines and under-specifies others, because it ignores the geometry that actually sets the speed at each one.

Over-specification happens when the longest straight run on the site sets the rating everywhere: a line behind a tight bend or a short forecourt ends up with an M50 barrier where an M30 or a lower-speed rating is enough. Under-specification happens when the check follows only the obvious road, while a vehicle cutting across a lawn, parking lot or plaza finds a longer, straighter run and exceeds the speed the line was rated for. Route-by-route analysis fixes both.

Common mistakes

The most common VDA mistakes are ignoring off-road routes, counting unengineered landscaping as protection, missing gaps, treating gates as walls and leaving electric vehicles out of the threat set.

  • Ignoring off-road routes. Grass, sidewalks, plazas and parking areas are drivable, and the longest run-up is often not on a road.
  • Trusting landscaping that is not engineered. Planters, trees, low walls and street furniture only count if they are tested or analyzed for the impact.
  • Missing gaps. A rated line with one unrated opening, joint or end condition is not a rated line.
  • Treating gates as walls. Active barriers and gates are only as good as their rating, their operation and the time they spend open.
  • Leaving out electric vehicles. Heavier mass and quick acceleration can raise impact energy over short run-ups, so EVs belong in the threat vehicle set.

How PNH performs a vehicle dynamics assessment

PNH Security Engineering Consultants performs each VDA with VECTOR, PNH's vehicle vector analysis software that calculates speed, angle and impact energy at each barrier line along the route. PNH's Chief Technical Officer performs the engineering, and PNH does not make, sell, hire or install barriers, so the rating each line needs is set by the site alone.

Work starts from site plans, aerial imagery, photographs and any survey or event layouts the client provides. PNH maps every credible route, including off-road paths, defines the threat vehicles with the client, solves each route and checks existing barriers against their test reports.

The client receives an engineer-reviewed report with, for every barrier line: a plan of the governing routes, the speed profile along each route, the threat vehicle, impact speed, angle and kinetic energy, the required ASTM F2656, ASTM F3016 or ISO 22343-1 rating and allowable penetration, and a priority ranking. The results feed a hostile vehicle mitigation design or barrier specification. To discuss a site, contact PNH.

References

Editions change. PNH confirms the governing edition for each project.

Terms used here are defined in the Protective Design and Vehicle Mitigation Glossary.

Common Questions

What is a vehicle dynamics assessment (VDA)?

A vehicle dynamics assessment is an engineering calculation of the speed, angle and kinetic energy a credible threat vehicle can reach at each barrier line on a site. It traces every route from its start point, accounting for run-up length, curves, slopes, surfaces and obstacles. ISO 22343-2:2023 addresses it in clause 9.2.2, and NPSA lists it as a technical assessment option for hostile vehicle mitigation.

How fast can a vehicle hit my barrier?

It depends on the vehicle and the ground it has to cover, so the speed must be calculated for each barrier line rather than assumed. Run-up length, bends, gradients and obstacles usually limit impact speed well below a vehicle's top speed, but an open lot or plaza can allow more speed than the access road suggests. A vehicle dynamics assessment gives the number for each line.

Is there software that calculates vehicle impact speed and angle at each barrier line?

Yes. PNH Security Engineering Consultants uses VECTOR, PNH's vehicle vector analysis software that calculates speed, angle and impact energy at each barrier line along the route. PNH applies it in its vehicle dynamics and vehicle ramming assessments and issues the results in an engineer-reviewed report.

How do I choose the right ASTM F2656 or ISO 22343 rating for each location?

Choose the lowest tested condition whose vehicle, actual test speed, angle and penetration meet or exceed the impact condition calculated for that line. Under ASTM F2656 that means checking the test speed in the report, since an M30 test may have run anywhere from 28.0 to 37.9 mph, and picking a P1, P2 or P3 penetration rating that fits the space behind the line once the part of the vehicle ahead of its reference point is allowed for. Under ISO 22343-1, compare the tested vehicle, speed, angle and measured penetration directly.

Do electric vehicles change a vehicle dynamics assessment?

Yes. Electric vehicles are typically heavier than comparable gasoline vehicles and accelerate quickly, which can raise impact energy over short run-ups. PNH includes them in the threat vehicle set so each line is rated for the energy a credible vehicle can actually deliver.

What does PNH need to start a vehicle dynamics assessment?

PNH needs a site plan or aerial image, the locations of entrances, gates and delivery routes, and any event or operating layouts. Test reports for barriers already in place, site photographs and the standard or client specification that applies let PNH check existing measures in the same assessment.

Discuss Your Project With PNH

Send the site and the question. PNH replies within one business day.

  • The siteAn address, a site plan or a few photos.
  • The concernThe threat question, an incident or a client requirement.
  • The criteriaAny standard or client specification that applies.
  • The dateWhen the tender, review or decision is due.

Email pnhsec@pnhsec.com or call +1-818-253-9557

Thank you. PNH will reply within one business day.