Home / Briefings / Holiday Markets

A VEHICLE RAMMING BRIEFING

One Open Gap

Protecting holiday markets and seasonal events from vehicle ramming: why recent attacks got through, and what to check before opening day.

By Pedram Hesam, PhD, PSP · Chief Technical Officer · · 6 minute read

Summary

A holiday market is only as safe as its weakest opening. In the four deadliest recent attacks on markets, parades and street festivals, barriers or closures were in place or planned, and the vehicle still found one unprotected path: an emergency lane left open, a sidewalk around a police car, a closed street with no hard cordon.

Seasonal events are harder to protect than permanent sites. They go up in days, sit on public streets, change layout every season, and are run by several parties at once. This briefing sets out what the record shows, why temporary sites fail, and what organizers and owners can check before opening day.

What the Record Shows

Each attack below hit a planned, announced, temporary crowd, and in each one the vehicle reached people through a gap rather than through a rated barrier.

DateEventKilled / injuredHow the vehicle reached the crowd
Jul 25, 2026Berlin Pride, Tiergarten1 / 29Rented van driven along a park footpath near the celebration, off the march route
Apr 26, 2025Lapu-Lapu Day festival, Vancouver11 / about 32 hospitalizedSUV entered a street closed for food trucks; the dump-truck cordon used at earlier city festivals was not there
Jan 1, 2025New Year, Bourbon Street, New Orleans14 / 57Pickup went onto the sidewalk around a police SUV; the permanent bollards had been removed for replacement
Dec 20, 2024Christmas market, Magdeburg6 / 309SUV used an emergency lane left open between concrete blocks; the planned chain was missing, the blocking police car about 30 m away
Recent vehicle attacks on markets, parades and festivals, newest first.

The pattern is consistent. The perimeter existed on paper, but one opening was unrated, unstaffed or unclosed at the moment it mattered. In Magdeburg the car covered at least 400 m in about one minute at up to 48 km/h (30 mph) once inside.

Illustrative event plan showing four gaps vehicles used in recent attacks: an emergency lane left open, a sidewalk around a parked vehicle, a closed street with only cones or signs, and a crowd beyond the barrier line. One open gap defeats the whole perimeter Illustrative event plan: the four ways vehicles reached recent crowds Market stalls and crowd parked vehicle 1 Emergency lane left openMagdeburg, Dec 2024 2 Sidewalk arounda parked vehicleNew Orleans, Jan 2025 3 Closed street, no hard cordonVancouver, Apr 2025 4 Crowd beyondthe barrier lineBerlin, Jul 2026 Barrier line Cones or signs, not a barrier Path the vehicle used
Figure 1. Four gap types on one illustrative event plan. Each one alone was enough to put a vehicle inside the crowd, however good the rest of the line was.

Why Seasonal Sites Are Harder Than Permanent Ones

A temporary event fails for organizational reasons more often than engineering ones. Four traits make it fragile:

  • Built in days, on public streets. Vehicle routes stay open until the last stall goes up, and the closures are often traffic-control devices, not barriers.
  • The layout changes every year. Stalls, stages and entrances move, so last season's barrier plan no longer matches the site.
  • Openings are designed in. Emergency lanes, delivery windows and vendor access are needed, and each one is a path for a hostile vehicle unless it is closed by a rated, staffed barrier.
  • No single owner. The city, police, organizer and vendors each hold part of the plan. Reporting on Magdeburg found the barrier plan named no one responsible for closing the gaps.

A past event with “zero issues” is not evidence of protection. Vancouver's festival had been assessed as low risk on that basis the year before.

Engineering the Approach

Protection starts with the vehicle, not the barrier catalog. For each edge of the event, the question is which vehicle can reach it, how fast, and at what angle.

  1. Map every approach. Streets, alleys, parking lots, sidewalks, plazas and lawns. A car does not need a road; New Orleans showed a sidewalk is enough.
  2. Set the demand at each opening. Run-up length, turns and slope limit the speed a vehicle can reach. That speed and the vehicle's mass set the impact energy the barrier must stop.
  3. Match the barrier to the demand. Choose temporary barriers tested to ASTM F2656 or ISO 22343-1 for the vehicle and speed that can actually arrive. Jersey barriers, planters, fencing and parked cars are not rated unless they were tested.
  4. Install them as tested. A rated barrier only performs on the surface, anchorage and spacing it was tested with. Clear gaps between elements must stay under the tested limit.
  5. Close the openings you need. Emergency and delivery lanes get a rated, movable barrier and a named person who opens and closes it, never a chain or an unattended vehicle.
  6. Check standoff behind the line. Allow for the barrier's rated penetration, so a stopped vehicle does not end up in the crowd.
Six steps: map every approach, set the credible speed and angle, find the impact energy, select a rated barrier, install it as tested, and keep standoff behind the line.The barrier is chosen after the vehicle demand is known1 Map every approachStreets, sidewalks, lots,lawns and plazas2 Credible speed, angleRun-up length, turns andslope at each opening3 Impact energyVehicle mass and speedset the demand4 Rated barrierTested to ASTM F2656 orISO 22343-1 for that demand5 Installed as testedSame surface, anchorageand clear spacing6 Standoff behind lineCrowd kept back beyondthe rated penetration
Figure 2. From approach path to rated barrier, in six steps. Picking a barrier from a catalog before steps 1 to 3 is how sites end up either underprotected or paying for more than they need.

This is the work PNH's VECTOR analysis does: it fixes the credible speed, angle and energy at each barrier line, so the event is protected where it is exposed and not overbuilt where it is not.

Beyond Barriers

Barriers stop the vehicle; people and procedures keep the barrier line closed. A layered plan adds:

  • Gate control. Every opening has a named owner, a schedule for when it opens, and a radio check when it closes.
  • Outer traffic management. Closures and speed controls further out reduce the speed a vehicle can build before it reaches the barrier line.
  • Crowd layout. Queues, stages and food lines are placed away from the vehicle edge, so the densest crowd is not the first thing a vehicle meets.
  • Watch and report. Staff and vendors know the warning signs CISA lists for vehicle attacks and whom to call.
  • Rehearsed response. Emergency access, casualty routes and public messaging are planned with the same barrier layout in place.
Security staff member in a high-visibility jacket holding a radio and clipboard beside a closed dark gray steel swing-arm vehicle barrier at a holiday market, with lit wooden stalls behind.
An emergency lane closed by a heavy swing-arm barrier that meets the fixed barrier units on both sides, with a named staff member in control of the gate.
Layered protection: outer traffic management, a rated barrier line with a staffed gate, a standoff zone, and the densest crowd at the center, supported by watch and report and a rehearsed response. Each layer covers what the one outside it can miss Outer traffic managementClosures and speed controls further out Barrier line, rated for the demand Staffed gatenamed owner, schedule, radio check Standoff zoneKept clear beyond the rated penetration Densest crowdQueues, stages and food lines Watch and reportStaff and vendors know the warning signs Rehearsed responseEmergency access, casualty routes, messaging
Figure 3. Layered protection for a seasonal event. The barrier line does the stopping; the layers outside it lower the speed, and the layers inside it keep a stopped vehicle away from people.

Checklist Before Opening Day

  • Every vehicle approach is on a current site plan, including sidewalks, lots and lawns.
  • Each barrier line has a credible vehicle, speed and angle, and the barrier is rated for that demand.
  • Barriers are installed on the surface and at the spacing they were tested with.
  • Every emergency and delivery opening has a rated movable barrier and a named person who controls it.
  • No opening relies on a chain, a parked car or a traffic cone.
  • The densest crowd areas sit back from the vehicle edge, beyond the barrier's rated penetration.
  • Organizer, city, police and vendors have signed off on one plan with one owner.
  • Staff have walked the perimeter at opening time, not only during setup.

Planning a market, parade or festival?

PNH assesses seasonal events and the venues that host them, independent of any barrier manufacturer. We map every approach, set the credible speed and energy at each opening with VECTOR, specify the barrier performance each line needs, and review the layout, the gate plan and the vendor submittals before opening day.

PNH does not make, sell or install barriers, so the recommendation follows the site. Learn more about our vehicle ramming assessment service.

Sources

  1. 2024 Magdeburg car attack. Wikipedia.
  2. 2025 New Orleans truck attack. Wikipedia.
  3. 2025 Vancouver car attack. Wikipedia.
  4. 2026 Berlin Pride attack. Wikipedia.
  5. Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency. Vehicle Ramming Action Guide. December 2024.
  6. Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency. Vehicle Incident Prevention and Mitigation Security Guide. April 2024.
Pedram Hesam, PhD, PSP

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Pedram Hesam, PhD, PSP, is Chief Technical Officer at PNH, where he leads protective design engineering practice in blast, impact, fragment and hostile vehicle mitigation for critical infrastructure and public facilities. He has more than 17 years of experience in blast and antiterrorism engineering and holds a PhD in Civil Engineering from Purdue University and the Physical Security Professional (PSP) credential from ASIS International. He is a voting member of ASTM Committee F12, which maintains the U.S. vehicle barrier test standards.

← All briefings