Home / Briefings / Vehicle Barrier Crash Ratings

Vehicle Barrier Crash Ratings: How to Read ASTM F2656, ASTM F3016 and ISO 22343-1

A vehicle barrier crash rating records what one barrier, built and founded one way, did in one full-scale test. PNH Security Engineering Consultants reads that evidence independently and checks whether it applies to the barrier a site will actually receive.

Technical guide by Pedram Hesam, PhD, PSP, Chief Technical Officer, PNH Security Engineering Consultants. Updated .

What does a vehicle barrier crash rating certify?

A crash rating certifies that a specific barrier, built and founded as tested, stopped a specific test vehicle at a measured speed and angle within a stated penetration distance in one full-scale test. It does not certify the barrier at any particular site.

ASTM F2656/F2656M-23 states that the penetration rating does not imply performance as rated in all site conditions, approach routes and topography, and that only a single test at a specified impact location is required, so other impact points may respond differently (5.2). It also states that certification addresses only the ability to withstand the test vehicle's impact, not operational suitability (1.3). A rating says nothing about other impact angles, a different foundation, the reliability of an active barrier, or the gaps between barriers.

What do ASTM F2656 M30, M40, M50 and P1, P2, P3 mean?

An ASTM F2656 rating such as M50 with a P1 penetration rating (often written M50-P1) means the barrier stopped a 15,000 lb standard test truck that struck it at 47.0 mph or more, and the truck's reference point traveled no more than 1 m (3.3 ft) past the barrier's pre-test leading impact edge.

The letters name the test vehicle and the number the nominal speed in mph. ASTM F2656/F2656M-23 (Table 1, 7.4) uses six vehicles: small passenger car SC (2,420 lb), full-size sedan FS (4,630 lb), pickup truck PU (5,000 lb), standard test truck M (15,000 lb, 6,800 kg), Class 7 cabover C7 (15,873 lb) and heavy goods vehicle H (65,000 lb). Nominal speeds are 30, 40 and 50 mph (50, 65 and 80 km/h), plus 60 mph (100 km/h) for SC, FS and PU, giving designations such as PU50, C740 and H50. Impact is head-on, at 90 degrees to the barrier. Speeds and penetration are both banded:

Rating elementMeaning under ASTM F2656/F2656M-23
M3015,000 lb truck, actual speed 28.0 to 37.9 mph
M4015,000 lb truck, actual speed 38.0 to 46.9 mph
M5015,000 lb truck, actual speed 47.0 mph and above
P1Dynamic penetration 1 m (3.3 ft) or less
P21.01 to 7 m (3.31 to 23.0 ft), reported with the distance, for example P2:6.4 m
P37.01 to 30 m (23.1 to 98.4 ft), reported with the distance

The rating uses dynamic penetration, the maximum reached during the crash (3.1.13, 3.1.16), not static penetration at rest. It runs from the barrier's pre-test leading impact edge to the vehicle reference point: the leading lower edge of the cargo bed for M, C7 and H trucks, and the base of the A-pillar for SC, FS and PU vehicles. Since the 2018 edition every rating is referenced to the leading impact edge, so read a report to an earlier edition for the reference points it used. The former P4 rating has been eliminated. Terms used here are defined in the protective design glossary.

Where ASTM F2656 penetration is measured
Illustrative side elevation of an ASTM F2656/F2656M-23 test. Penetration is measured from the barrier's pre-test leading impact edge to the vehicle reference point: the leading lower edge of the cargo bed for M, C7 and H trucks, or the base of the A-pillar for SC, FS and PU vehicles; the truck's cab and engine sit ahead of that point. Dynamic penetration, the maximum during the crash, sets the rating: P1 up to 1 m (3.3 ft), P2 1.01 to 7 m (3.31 to 23.0 ft), P3 7.01 to 30 m (23.1 to 98.4 ft); static penetration at rest does not.ASTM F2656/F2656M-23: where penetration is measuredHead-on impact at 90 degrees. Vehicle travels left to right.A. Reference pointsBarrierDirection of travelCab and engine extend aheadof the truck reference pointTruck reference point (M, C7, H):leading lower edge of the cargo bedBarrier reference point:pre-test leading impact edgeCars and pickups (SC, FS, PU)Reference point (red dot):base of the A-pillarB. Penetration rating (dynamic)P1up to 1 m(3.3 ft)P21.01 to 7 m(3.31 to 23.0 ft)P37.01 to 30 m(23.1 to 98.4 ft)01 m7 m30 mDistance past the leading impact edge (not to scale)P2:6.4 mDynamic penetration: the maximum duringthe crash. This sets the rating.Static penetration: where the vehiclecomes to rest. It does not set the rating.Example: M50-P1 means the truck reference pointtraveled no more than 1 m (3.3 ft) past the edge.Illustrative, not to scale. Vehicles per ASTM F2656/F2656M-23 Table 1 and 7.4; dynamic penetration per 3.1.13 and 3.1.16.P2 and P3 are reported with the distance, for example P2:6.4 m. Since the 2018 edition every rating is referenced to the leading impact edge.
Under ASTM F2656/F2656M-23, penetration runs from the barrier's pre-test leading impact edge to the vehicle reference point, and the dynamic (maximum) value sets the P1, P2 or P3 rating. Illustrative, not to scale.

What is ASTM F3016 and what do S ratings mean?

ASTM F3016/F3016M-19 is a low-speed test method that rates protective devices for storefronts and pedestrian areas against a 5,000 lb surrogate test vehicle at nominal 10, 20 or 30 mph, designated S10, S20 and S30.

ASTM lists the edition approved August 1, 2019 as active. Its introduction names uses such as storefronts and pedestrians at nose-in parking, bus stops, restaurant patios, and propane tanks or gas pumps. The surrogate, modeled on the AASHTO MASH 2270P pickup truck (7.4.1), travels perpendicular to the device.

Rating elementMeaning under ASTM F3016/F3016M-19
S10Nominal 10 mph (20 km/h), actual 9 to 18.9 mph
S20Nominal 20 mph (35 km/h), actual 19 to 27.4 mph
S30Nominal 30 mph (50 km/h), actual 27.5 to 32.5 mph
P1Dynamic penetration 1 ft (0.30 m) or less
P21 to 4 ft (0.31 to 1.22 m)
FailureMore than 4 ft (1.23 m or more)

F3016 P ratings are not F2656 P ratings: penetration is the greater of the device's displacement and the impactor nose's intrusion into the protected area behind the device (3.1.10, 3.1.14), with no cargo bed involved. Testing starts in washed sand; a device whose foundation moves 1 in. (25 mm) or less is considered rigid, otherwise a second test on a concrete slab can be rated (7.5.1). An S30 rating addresses a low-speed impact by a pickup-size vehicle; it is not evidence against a deliberate attack by a heavier or faster vehicle. See storefront protection.

How do ISO 22343-1, IWA 14-1 and PAS 68 ratings work?

ISO 22343-1:2023 rates a barrier by the values actually measured in its test: vehicle mass and class, impact speed, impact angle, vehicle penetration and major debris distance, rather than by speed bands.

A rating reads, for example, V/7200[N3C]/48/90:2.6/5.0 (an illustrative code): a 7,200 kg N3C truck at 48 km/h and 90 degrees, 2.6 m vehicle penetration and 5.0 m major debris distance. Vehicle classes run from a 1,500 kg car (M1) to a 30,000 kg heavy goods vehicle (N3G), and the angle may be any value above 0 and up to 90 degrees. Penetration is measured from a datum line at the foremost point of the structure designed to resist impact, not the foundation's front face, and the method applies to vehicle penetration up to 25 m (82 ft).

ISO 22343-1:2023 is a first edition (September 2023) that cancels and replaces IWA 14-1:2013. IWA 14-1 and PAS 68 are withdrawn, but the UK National Protective Security Authority (NPSA) treats existing results to them as valid unless the as-tested barrier has been changed. PAS 68 measured penetration from the barrier's rear face, IWA 14-1 and ISO 22343-1 from the front.

Reading an ISO 22343-1 rating code
Decoder for an illustrative ISO 22343-1:2023 rating code, V/7200[N3C]/48/90:2.6/5.0: vehicle impact test, 7,200 kg test vehicle, class N3C, 48 km/h measured impact speed, 90 degree impact angle, 2.6 m vehicle penetration and 5.0 m major debris distance. Below, an illustrative barrier section compares datums: ISO 22343-1 and IWA 14-1 measure from a datum line at the foremost point of the structure designed to resist impact, not the foundation's front face; ASTM F2656 from the pre-test leading impact edge; the withdrawn PAS 68 from the barrier's rear face.ISO 22343-1:2023: reading a rating code and its datumThe code records values measured in the test, not speed bands.V/7200[N3C]/48/90:2.6/5.0VVehicle impacttest7200Test vehiclemass, kg[N3C]Vehicle class(N3C truck)48Impact speed,km/h (measured)90Impact angle,degrees2.6Vehiclepenetration, m5.0Major debrisdistance, mIllustrative code: a 7,200 kg N3C truck at 48 km/h and 90 degrees, 2.6 m vehicle penetration, 5.0 m major debris distance.Where each standard measures penetration from (barrier section)BarrierVehicle approachProtected sideFoundation front face:not the datumISO 22343-1 and IWA 14-1: datum line at the foremostpoint of the structure designed to resist impactASTM F2656: pre-test leading impact edgePAS 68 (withdrawn): rear faceof the barrierMeasured this wayIllustrative, not to scale. A plain vertical-faced barrier is shown, so the ASTM F2656 leading impact edge and the ISO datum fall on thesame line here. ISO 22343-1:2023 cancels and replaces IWA 14-1:2013 and applies to vehicle penetration up to 25 m (82 ft).
An illustrative ISO 22343-1:2023 code decoded field by field, and the point each standard measures penetration from: the front datum line for ISO 22343-1 and IWA 14-1 (not the foundation's front face), the pre-test leading impact edge for ASTM F2656, and the rear face for the withdrawn PAS 68.

What happened to Department of State K4, K8 and K12 ratings?

K4, K8 and K12 are legacy U.S. Department of State ratings for a 15,000 lb truck at nominal 30, 40 and 50 mph, replaced in U.S. practice by ASTM F2656 condition designations.

Their standard, SD-STD-02.01, was first published in April 1985 with penetration limits of 1 m (3 ft), 6 m (20 ft) and 15 m (50 ft), measured from the barrier's attack face to the final resting position of the front of the truck's frame rails. Revision A (2003) kept only the 1 m limit, measured from the barrier's inside (non-impact) face to the front of the cargo bed at the vehicle's final position. ASTM F2656-07 built on Revision A, and the Department of State adopted it in October 2008, effective February 1, 2009. K12 is often presented as M50-P1, but M50-P1 measures dynamic penetration from the leading impact edge, so they are not automatically the same.

Why are equivalencies between rating standards only approximate?

Ratings under different standards are only approximately equivalent because the standards use different vehicles, speed rules, angles and penetration reference points.

ItemASTM F2656/F2656M-23ASTM F3016/F3016M-19ISO 22343-1:2023
VehiclesSix, 2,420 to 65,000 lbOne 5,000 lb surrogateClasses from 1,500 to 30,000 kg
SpeedBand per designationBand per S designationActual measured speed
Angle90 degrees90 degreesGreater than 0 to 90 degrees, stated
PenetrationP1 to P3 bands from leading impact edgeP1, P2 or failure, into protected areaMeasured distance from datum line
DebrisNot part of the ratingNot part of the ratingMajor debris distance in the rating

A 7,200 kg N3C test at 48 km/h (about 30 mph) resembles an ASTM M30 test, but the trucks differ and M30 spans 28.0 to 37.9 mph. PNH compares tests on the actual mass, speed, kinetic energy, angle and penetration in each report. The required values come from a vehicle dynamics assessment of each barrier line.

Speed bands versus measured speed
Speed comparison on one mph axis with a km/h scale. ASTM F3016/F3016M-19 bands for a 5,000 lb surrogate: S10 9 to 18.9 mph, S20 19 to 27.4 mph, S30 27.5 to 32.5 mph. ASTM F2656/F2656M-23 bands for the 15,000 lb M truck: M30 28.0 to 37.9 mph, M40 38.0 to 46.9 mph, M50 47.0 mph and above. ISO 22343-1:2023 has no bands: each test states its measured speed, shown as one illustrative point at 48 km/h (about 30 mph) for a 7,200 kg N3C truck, which falls inside both the S30 and M30 bands although the vehicles differ.Speed: bands under ASTM, measured values under ISOEach standard sets its speed differently, so ratings do not convert one to one.mph0102030405060ASTM F3016/F3016M-195,000 lb surrogateASTM F2656/F2656M-23M truck, 15,000 lbISO 22343-1:2023Measured speed, onevalue per test, no bandS109 to 18.9S2019 to 27.4S3027.5 to 32.5M3028.0 to 37.9M4038.0 to 46.9M5047.0 and above48 km/h (about 30 mph): illustrative 7,200 kg N3C testkm/h02040608048 km/h lies inside both S30 and M30, yet the vehicles differ: a 5,000 lb surrogate, a 15,000 lb truck and a 7,200 kg truck.Compare tests on the actual mass, speed, kinetic energy, angle and penetration in each report.Illustrative ISO point. Bands per ASTM F3016/F3016M-19 and ASTM F2656/F2656M-23 (M vehicle shown); the km/h scale is a unit conversion.
ASTM F3016 and ASTM F2656 rate speed in bands, while ISO 22343-1 states the speed measured in each test. An illustrative 48 km/h (about 30 mph) ISO test falls inside both the S30 and M30 bands, yet the vehicles differ, so ratings do not convert directly.

How do I read a vehicle barrier crash test report?

Read a crash test report for who tested what, at what speed and angle, how far the vehicle went, and exactly what was built.

  1. Standard, edition and laboratory. The edition matters, since penetration reference points changed with the 2018 edition (F2656/F2656M-18). ASTM F2656 requires an accredited facility (7.2.1): a laboratory accredited in accordance with ISO/IEC 17025 and led by a test director (3.1.2).
  2. Test vehicle and mass. Check the class and the measured mass against its tolerance (for M, 15,000 plus or minus 309 lb).
  3. Actual impact speed and angle. Read the measured values, not only the designation.
  4. Penetration. Find the dynamic value and its reference points; static penetration does not set an F2656 rating.
  5. Test article. F2656 makes the supplier's drawings and specifications part of the permanent record (4.1). Check the model, number of bollards or span length tested, spacing and end conditions against what will be installed.
  6. Foundation and soil. Check foundation drawings and soil; embedded barriers are tested in low-cohesive crushed stone or gravel (7.2.2), and deviations from drawings must be noted (7.3).
  7. Evidence. Look for photographs, measurements and high-speed video at 400 frames per second or more (6.3, 6.5). For ISO 22343-1, read the full classification code.

Rated, tested and certified by calculation: what each means

Only "rated" means a passed full-scale test of that model and configuration under a named standard; the other terms can mean much less.

  • Rated. A full-scale test met the criteria of a named standard and edition, documented in a test report.
  • Tested. A test was run; it may have failed, departed from the method or used another configuration.
  • Certificate. A one-page certificate summarizes a test; it is only as good as the report behind it.
  • Certified by calculation, or "equivalent to". Analysis or simulation can help an engineer judge a variation from a tested design, but it is not a crash rating under ASTM F2656, ASTM F3016 or ISO 22343-1.

Is a crash-rated bollard still rated if installed differently from the test?

No: a rating applies to the barrier as tested, so a bollard on a different foundation, spacing, ground or line arrangement is not covered by the rating itself.

ASTM F2656 requires the test article to be built and erected representative of the proposed actual service installation (7.3). NPSA and NaCTSO guidance states that ratings only apply to the as-tested configuration, layout or arrangement. Common departures:

  • Foundation and ground. Shallower or narrower footings, different reinforcement, weaker soil, slabs over basements or vaults, or foundations cut around utilities.
  • Shallow-mount versus deep-mount. The two are not interchangeable; a shallow-mount rating depends on the tested foundation extent and the ground under it.
  • Spacing and continuity. Wider gaps, or fewer bollards tied into a common foundation than were tested.

Checklist for owners and architects

Before accepting a crash-rated barrier, an owner or architect should confirm the full test report, the standard and rating, the measured results, matching installation drawings, the treatment of gaps and line ends, and a performance-based specification. In detail:

  • The full test report, from an accredited laboratory, for the exact model and configuration
  • The standard and edition, and a rating that meets the impact condition calculated for that line
  • Actual test speed, angle and dynamic penetration, compared with the clear distance behind the line
  • Installation drawings that match the tested foundation, spacing and end conditions, or a sealed engineering analysis for each departure
  • Gaps, gates and line ends treated to the same performance
  • Specifications that name the standard and performance, not a product

How PNH reviews vendor test evidence

PNH Security Engineering Consultants reviews crash test evidence independently, because PNH does not make, sell, hire or install barriers and has no product to favor.

PNH's Chief Technical Officer performs the review. PNH reads the full test report against the impact condition required at each barrier line, checks installation drawings against the tested article, and flags invalid conversions between standards and departures that need analysis. The result feeds a hostile vehicle mitigation design, a vehicle ramming assessment or a performance specification. To have test evidence reviewed, contact PNH.

References

Editions change. PNH confirms the governing edition for each project.

Terms used here are defined in the Protective Design and Vehicle Mitigation Glossary.

Common Questions

What does an ASTM F2656 M30 P1 rating mean?

It means the barrier stopped a 15,000 lb standard test truck that struck it at an actual speed between 28.0 and 37.9 mph, with dynamic penetration of 1 m (3.3 ft) or less. Penetration is measured from the barrier's pre-test leading impact edge to the leading lower edge of the truck's cargo bed. M40 and M50 use the same truck at higher speed bands.

Is ISO 22343-1 the same as ASTM F2656?

No. ISO 22343-1:2023 reports the actual vehicle mass and class, speed, angle, penetration and major debris distance, while ASTM F2656/F2656M-23 assigns a speed designation and a penetration band at a 90 degree impact. Results can be compared approximately using the actual values in each test report, but one is not a direct conversion of the other.

What is an ASTM F3016 S30 rating?

An S30 rating under ASTM F3016/F3016M-19 means a protective device was tested with a 5,000 lb surrogate vehicle at an actual speed of 27.5 to 32.5 mph. It is paired with a P1 (1 ft or less) or P2 (1 to 4 ft) penetration rating. F3016 is intended for low-speed impacts at storefronts and pedestrian areas, not for heavier or faster deliberate attacks.

Is a K12 barrier the same as an M50 barrier?

Not automatically. K12 was a U.S. Department of State rating for a 15,000 lb truck at nominal 50 mph; under SD-STD-02.01 Revision A (2003) penetration had to be 1 m or less, measured from the barrier's inside face to the front of the cargo bed at the vehicle's final position. ASTM F2656 measures dynamic penetration from the leading impact edge, so the original test report must be read before treating K12 as M50-P1.

Does a crash rating cover a shallower foundation or a retrofit into an existing slab?

Only if that foundation is the one that was tested. ASTM F2656 requires the test article to represent the proposed service installation, and NPSA and NaCTSO guidance limits a rating to the as-tested configuration. A different footing, soil, slab or anchorage needs engineering analysis of the change, which supports a judgment, not a crash rating.

What should I ask a barrier vendor for?

Ask for the full crash test report from an accredited laboratory for the exact model and configuration, including the foundation drawings. Check the actual speed, angle and dynamic penetration, and compare the tested installation with the drawings for your site. PNH reviews this evidence independently.

Discuss Your Project With PNH

Send the site and the question. PNH replies within one business day.

  • The siteAn address, a site plan or a few photos.
  • The concernThe threat question, an incident or a client requirement.
  • The criteriaAny standard or client specification that applies.
  • The dateWhen the tender, review or decision is due.

Email pnhsec@pnhsec.com or call +1-818-253-9557

Thank you. PNH will reply within one business day.